关于燃油交输活门开位是否导致燃油不平衡的问题讨论

SR 3-5484124776

2022年11月,运行中有飞机反应发生燃油不平衡警告,经确认为在左右油箱泵均打开的情况下,交输活门未关闭。在交输活门未关闭是否为导致燃油不平衡的问题上存在争议,一种认为每个泵出口压力都一致,那么就该各供各发的燃油,即使开着交输活门也不应该发生这一问题。就此与波音做了沟通。相关答复如下:

R1: Boeing confirms that the opened Crossfeed valve could potentially lead to the Fuel Imbalance condition described in the Ref /F/. Boeing notes that there is no Boeing procedure that requires the fuel Crossfeed valve to be open for an extended period of time in normal two-engine operations with all fuel pumps operating. The Crossfeed valve is verified being closed before departure (refer to the Ref /H/ attached FCOM extract) and stays closed during the whole flight unless a Fuel Balancing Procedure (refer to the Ref /I/) needs to be performed or if directed by the Non-Normal Checklist.

R2: Boeing highly recommends Hainan Airlines (HNA) follow the FCOM procedure and switch the Crossfeed valve to the Closed position during regular flights.

就从系统工作角度理解如下:

结合译码的情况,还原整个事件的过程如下:地面左右油箱加油后,使用APU,如果不开泵会消耗左主油箱的油量。但从发动机启动阶段的油量可知,右主油箱(8290LB)是少于左主油箱(8420LB)的。表明有打右主油箱泵并开了交输活门,才会让APU消耗的是右主油箱的油量。随后在打开左主油箱前后泵启动发动机时,交输活门仍然在开位,相当于总管中同时有4个泵提供燃油。由于每个泵的输出流量是会存在差异的(只要满足最低流量要求),同时供给总管也会存差异。厂家在FIM手册中28-41 TASK 820对于燃油构型问题的可能性中,就包括交输活门未完全关闭。表明交输活门的不完全关闭尚且会产生不平衡的状态,何况完全打开的情况。

关于油箱体积和密度的相关数据

SR 4-5603166506

相关分析也可参见技术说明区文档。

R1. Flashing of the refuel gage (indicator) is set to occur between the Volumetric Top Off (VTO) point (where the float switch begins to close), and the point in which fuel starts to transfer into the surge tank.  The goal is to warn the refueler that the automatic refuel shutoff system (float switch, refuel valve and the associated wires) may have failed to stop the refueling, in an effort to prevent fuel spills out of the surge tanks. VTO is set at a point where there is at least 2% expansion space remaining in the fuel tank per Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR) 25.969. This provides a 2% tank volume of window to detect a failure of the automatic refuel shutoff system. The surge tank is not included in the 2% expansion space. If fuel starts to transfer fuel into the surge tank, the FQIS measured volume is at its maximum. Therefore, there will not be a further increase in airplane indicated fuel volume as there are no fuel quantity probes in the surge tank, and the fuel level in the tanks is no longer increasing. The fuel float switch will stop the refueling at VTO, which will fluctuate depending on the fuel density and temperature at the airplane.  Fuel quantity in mass is the tank volume times the fuel density.

In addition, Boeing conducted ground testing at nominal ground attitude. Based on the results of these tests, VTO was determined to be as follows:

737NG Usable Fuel Capacity:

–   Main Tank 1 (1292) gallons,

–   Main Tank 2 (1284) gallons,

–   Main Tank average (1288) gallons,

–   Center Tank (4299) gallons.

Note – The expansion space for the main tanks is approximately 26 gallons Note – The expansion space for the center tank is approximately 85 gallons

737NG Overfill Indication (Refuel gage flashing):

–   Main Tank 1 & 2 (1296) gallons,

–   Center Tank (4301) gallons.

R2. Each fuel quantity indicator must be calibrated to read “zero” during level flight when the quantity of fuel remaining in the tank is equal to the unusable fuel supply determined under § 25.959.

In according with the 14 CFR § 25.959:

“The unusable fuel quantity for each fuel tank and its fuel system components must be established at not less than the quantity at which the first evidence of engine malfunction occurs under the most adverse fuel feed condition for all intended operations and flight maneuvers involving fuel feeding from that tank. Fuel system component failures need not be considered.”

All Boeing aircraft are designed to indicate the Usable Fuel available for aircraft propulsion. All the fuel in the Center and Main tanks indicated by FQIS is Usable Fuel. Please refer to the appropriate Weight and Balance Manual (WBM) for the Usable and Unusable fuel terms definitions and quantity tables.

R3. The “usable” fuel quantity will be approximately the same as the FQIS calculated fuel quantity at VTO (where the fuel float switch actuated) provided the FQIS is working properly.

R4. The “usable” fuel tank capacities should be used to calculate the fuel tank quantities. The remaining fuel in the tanks after the pumps have shut off is “unusable fuel” and should not be counted with for the next flight plan.

波音SR里也承认了他们使用的密度是常温下全球范围内燃油的典型密度。除非航司主动要求,否则,他们就用6.7LB/Gal做为密度。如果选装密度计的构型,精确度会更高。

[ Back To Top ]